Sarah Morgan

Healthcare Geek.
Professional Communicator.

Google: Just a Little Bit Scary

This winter, Google CEO Eric Schmidt said, “If you have something that you don’t want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place.”

I saw the quote in an Australian infographic video that’s pretty fear-mongering when it comes to Google, so I wasn’t sure it was accurate. But I did my homework, and not only did he say it – he said it on CNBC.

Google’s breadth is intimidating to begin with, but a sentiment like Schmidt’s zooms right past privacy concerns into basic human rights.

Why would we have anything that we don’t want anyone to know, Eric? I don’t know, why do they make doors with locks on them? Why do we have doors at all? Why do we have walls? Why isn’t life lived in one giant cattle car, one massive open plan?

Because, Eric, the ability to keep yourself protected and feeling secure is a basic human need, one that is negated when someone removes your ability to do something that no one knows about. It’s Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.

If what I need safe can’t be as protected as I want it to be, that’s knocking out that rung, and it’s only the second one up. The only things more basic are physiological needs. I won’t get to fulfilling needs like love, belonging, esteem, let alone self-actualization – not if I don’t feel safe.

The world Eric Schmidt is describing is one in which creativity like that which formed Google could not be possible.

Don’t get me started about options. I know I can choose to not have Google locate me on Latitude, share my read articles on Reader, etc. I know. But the point is, they’ve become so big that that becomes a flawed argument. It’s becoming increasingly like saying well, you could choose not to have the internet at all. I could choose not to eat any animal products, I could choose to only use words that don’t have the letter P in them. But if you choose a fairly common way to live your life, you should not be required to give up basic human rights to do so.

Comments

Sarah Morgan

Thanks Vanessa! I’m glad you agree.

Vanessa

am suggesting this as a read on my facebook… wow
What you have to say in response is a common sense and yet extremely cogent argument.

[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Laura Gajewski. Laura Gajewski said: Google: Just a Little Bit Scary http://is.gd/aukfH […]

Sarah Morgan

That’s a great point, Mike, and one that gives me hope. Let’s choose to believe that he was going for an edgy sound bite, not necessarily a crystallization of his morality or business plan!

mike hensgen

loved your above on Schmidt’s either drug-induced or other-planetary statement…I’m not a closed-in guy, but you’re very correct in saying it’s a natural NEED to be private , sometimes.

maybe this was just another example of a very well known, very “out front” personality grasping for an interview bite that contributes to their already cosmic self- (others’) perceptions

Leave A Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *